Actuaries share their post-pandemic insights
June 2024
Photograph: Getty Pictures/lerbank
The COVID-19 pandemic definitely affected virtually all aspects of life, together with the way in which we dwell, work, socialize and handle our funds. A few of the impacts look like enduring, reflecting a brand new regular within the post-pandemic world.
Talking to my very own expertise, grocery purchasing has all the time ranked low on my checklist of chores. Nevertheless, the pandemic launched me to a game-changing service: having groceries delivered on to my doorstep. This newfound comfort has change into a necessary a part of my life. That is one thing that represents a secondary and ongoing impact of COVID-19.
Over the previous few weeks, I’ve had the privilege of participating in discussions with fellow actuaries who work in several insurance coverage sectors, together with well being, life, incapacity and group merchandise, pension, and property and casualty (P&C). We delved into observations surrounding a few of the secondary impacts of COVID-19 on our respective sectors. Let’s discover the insights.
Brian Waterproof coat, FSA, MAAA, Well being Actuary and Chief Actuary at Blue Cross & Blue Defend of Rhode Island
As everyone knows, COVID-19 had vital impacts on the medical insurance market through the peak of the pandemic. Lots of these disruptions are behind us now, however by way of lingering and long-term results, listed below are a few of my ideas.
Well being Care Provide and Demand
Traditionally, there was a gradual and constant provide of well being care suppliers to accommodate the widely growing demand for well being care in the US. Nevertheless, the pandemic disrupted each of these long-term developments in 2020, and we nonetheless see impacts immediately in 2024.
The pandemic brought about a big disruption within the provide and demand dynamics of the well being care market. Within the spring of 2020, hospitals have been overwhelmed with growing instances of COVID-19 and made the choice to defer all elective procedures. It is very important be aware that “elective” procedures are usually not essentially beauty or non-compulsory; somewhat, the time period refers to procedures that weren’t deemed to be emergencies that required rapid consideration. Some studies counsel that as much as 80% of surgical procedures fall into this class. The results of these deferrals was a situation of zero provide however regular demand.
Subsequently, insurers and suppliers struggled to estimate when, or if, these deferred procedures could be rescheduled. Although lots of the initially deferred procedures have been rescheduled by now, there are lingering results attributable to the pandemic. For instance, we’re observing larger charges of sure cancers being recognized in later levels than was typical. As reports counsel, this might be attributed to canceled screening appointments through the pandemic, which could have in any other case caught these situations at earlier, extra treatable levels.
The Affiliation of American Medical Schools (AAMC) initiatives an impending physician shortage in the US, attributed to the ageing doctor workforce and an older and sicker U.S. affected person inhabitants. This was exacerbated by an alarming variety of U.S. physicians and well being care staff leaving the workforce because the onset of the pandemic, as reports present.
Rethink What ‘Catastrophic’ Means
Like all insurers, medical insurance firms historically put aside reserves to pay claims. Firms construct up reserves over time to determine robust risk-based capital ranges to resist monetary shocks. Pandemic threat traditionally has been cited for instance of such monetary shocks, the place strong reserves could be vital to resist the excessive prices and quantity of claims related to a pandemic.
Nevertheless, the COVID-19 pandemic proved to be markedly completely different from what was anticipated. Within the spring of 2020, notably in March and April, most elective procedures got here to a halt. Whereas pharmacy declare utilization continued with comparatively little influence, medical claims declined dramatically. Surprisingly, even the prices related to COVID-19 instances didn’t offset the numerous drop in elective procedures. Dental companies, to at least one excessive, noticed practically no utilization throughout that point.
Medical insurance firms typically scenario-test catastrophic conditions for enterprise threat administration (ERM) or different functions. The COVID-19 pandemic supplied a real-world instance of a catastrophic occasion that, not less than with regard to near-term well being care prices, proved to be a lot completely different than anticipated. It’s necessary to acknowledge that not all catastrophic eventualities may have equal impacts throughout all dimensions, together with monetary, societal, well being and supplier disruptions, and operational impacts.
Most cancers Charges and Screenings
The shutdown of many well being care companies in 2020, notably through the preliminary phases of the COVID-19 pandemic, considerably affected most cancers screenings and preventive visits. Routine screenings have been typically canceled or postponed to prioritize sources for COVID-19 therapy and cut back the chance of virus transmission. Many people who in any other case would have been recognized with most cancers throughout that point didn’t obtain well timed screenings or follow-up care. In consequence, there was a notable decline in new most cancers diagnoses in 2020. Some studies have proven that early-stage most cancers diagnoses decreased by practically 20% within the first yr of the COVID-19 pandemic.
One vital consequence of diminished screenings in 2020 is that new most cancers diagnoses in 2021 and past have been typically at a later stage. This delay in analysis led to worse outcomes for sufferers and better prices related to extra complicated therapies. Studies have proven that late-stage most cancers diagnoses elevated following the disruptions of the pandemic, underscoring the significance of well timed screenings and preventive care in detecting most cancers early.
Vaccine Uptake in Basic
A development of stagnated or declined vaccination charges predated the COVID-19 pandemic. The onset of the pandemic appeared to have accelerated the development of decrease vaccine uptake in the US. Particularly throughout 2020 and 2021, the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted routine well being care supply and brought about a decline within the quantity of really helpful vaccinations administered throughout the US (not simply COVID-19 vaccines, however all vaccines).
This might have main inhabitants well being impacts sooner or later as “herd immunity” wears off, and we may see extra outbreaks of in any other case vaccine-preventable illnesses.
Rob Frasca, FSA, CERA, Life Actuary and Managing Director at Ernst & Younger LLP
Disruption in Mortality Expertise
COVID-19 considerably affected mortality patterns worldwide. The extent of this influence diversified relying on components corresponding to geographic location, inhabitants demographics, well being care infrastructure and public well being measures.
Now that we’re a couple of years previous the height of the pandemic, a key query actuaries face is whether or not and tips on how to incorporate knowledge impacted by COVID-19 into expertise evaluation. I’ve seen firms not use expertise from 2020 and 2021 in any respect, some use it with out adjustment, and others make changes, corresponding to eliminating COVID-19 deaths from complete mortality. One of many key concerns is to evaluate the standard and reliability of the information. For some merchandise, termination knowledge might not reliably differentiate between deaths and lapse. For many who gather cause-of-death info, COVID-19 demise reporting could be difficult by numerous components, together with comorbidities.
Ancillary Impacts
The ancillary impacts of rising rates of interest, influenced by numerous components, together with pandemic-related authorities interventions and financial insurance policies, have had vital implications for the life insurance coverage business. The Coronavirus Assist, Reduction and Financial Safety (CARES) Act pushed $2 trillion of stimulus into the financial system in response to the consequences of COVID-19. It has been reported that elevated authorities spending and aid measures led to inflationary pressures, which in flip led the Federal Reserve to lift rates of interest.
We’ve seen notable modifications available in the market for insurance coverage merchandise consequently. Fastened annuities supply assured rates of interest, which have change into extra engaging to policyholders as market rates of interest have risen. Policyholders holding current fastened annuities at decrease rates of interest might select to give up their contracts and buy new ones providing larger charges, resulting in larger lapses. I’m seeing some insurers change into extra aggressive in providing aggressive crediting charges on fastened annuities and, to a lesser extent, on common life insurance coverage insurance policies to draw and retain policyholders.
I additionally am seeing elevated merger and acquisition (M&A) actions, partly pushed by the rising rate of interest atmosphere. Rates of interest influence the valuation of insurance coverage firms’ liabilities, notably for long-duration merchandise like annuities and life insurance coverage. Larger rates of interest translate into larger asset yields, which, in flip, cut back the current worth of future legal responsibility money flows, guaranteeing blocks of enterprise extra engaging targets for acquisition.
Jim Filmore, FSA, MAAA, VP and Actuary at Munich Re, Answerable for Group and Residing Advantages Pricing
Group Life
The direct influence of COVID-19 on mortality merchandise—like particular person life and group life—must be well-known at this level. The most important related variations between the 2 merchandise are the age distribution of the enterprise and the diploma of medical underwriting on the time of concern. The influence of the COVID-19 pandemic diversified by age, which is why we monitor our expertise by product, together with segmentation by age.
Along with the direct influence, there have been secondary impacts from the COVID-19 pandemic. For instance, these of their 20s, 30s and 40s had a cloth enhance in non-COVID-19 causes of demise, largely from exterior causes, together with motorcar accidents, drug overdoses and homicides. Quite a few these developments had been occurring previous to the pandemic, however the pandemic exacerbated them. We anticipate to proceed to see group life claims with COVID-19 as the first reason for demise. Nevertheless, these elevated deaths have come down dramatically from their pandemic highs, and in some unspecified time in the future, the general mortality will revert to pre-pandemic ranges. Within the meantime, it’s the non-COVID-19 extra deaths that we’re fastidiously monitoring for our mortality merchandise.
Incapacity Insurance coverage
Incapacity insurance coverage could be intently associated to the financial cycle, notably in response to patterns of recession and fluctuations in unemployment charges. Nevertheless, the COVID-19 turbulence had completely different traits from the earlier financial downturn of 2008. Whereas the 2008 recession primarily affected the monetary sector and housing market, the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted virtually all sectors, notably hospitality, journey, leisure and retail. Furthermore, the magnitude and pace of the decline and restoration in employment through the COVID-19 recession have been unprecedented. This created lots of uncertainty throughout Q2 and Q3 of 2020.
Regardless of that, and now in hindsight, for incapacity merchandise together with particular person incapacity earnings and long-term incapacity, the direct influence on morbidity because of COVID-19 has been minimal. Nevertheless, we proceed to observe the enterprise for secondary impacts. Two examples of potential secondary impacts on incapacity morbidity are impacts from a recession associated to the pandemic and long-COVID. At this level, now we have not seen a cloth influence on incapacity morbidity from both of these secondary causes and are optimistic that it will proceed to be the case.
As well as, we consider that the elevated skill to work remotely is one cause now we have been in a interval of favorable incapacity morbidity. It won’t be related whether or not the person is definitely exercising the choice to do business from home. Relatively, the choice to do business from home both totally or a part of the time may probably enhance morbidity expertise by permitting the insured to proceed working.
Elizabeth Walsh, FSA, MAAA, Pension Actuary and Vice President at TIAA
Within the pension and retirement market, we noticed rapid and direct impacts from COVID-19. There even have been long-lasting oblique impacts by way of the financial recession and market volatility led to by the pandemic. I’ll speak about these from the views of members and insurance coverage firms within the pension and retirement market, and I’ll additionally share potential outlooks.
Member Conduct Modifications
The pandemic created hardship for a lot of, notably those that misplaced their jobs and wanted rapid monetary help. The CARES Act was enacted through the peak of the pandemic and allowed people affected by COVID-19 to withdraw from their retirement financial savings plans, together with 401(ok) plans and IRA accounts, with out incurring early withdrawal penalties. This supplied rapid monetary aid. Nevertheless, this additionally meant a lower in retirement funds, and along with misplaced earnings through the pandemic, it’s anticipated that some people should work longer and retire later than initially deliberate.
The pandemic additionally created disruptions within the monetary markets. Because of elevated market volatility, people are reevaluating their retirement fund methods, choosing extra conservative approaches and prioritizing stability and safety of their funding methods. Take 401(ok)s, for instance. We sometimes see those that are 20 or 30 years away from retirement choosing extra aggressive portfolios and those that are nearer to retirement choosing extra conservative portfolios. Nevertheless, primarily based on my expertise post-pandemic, we’re seeing those that are far-off from retirement additionally making a shift towards extra conservative portfolios as they’ve caught with the modifications in retirement-saving conduct led to by the pandemic.
Firm Views
Typically talking, firms noticed an preliminary dip in account steadiness because of decreased ranges of contribution and funding exercise and people making withdrawals towards retirement funds. Nevertheless, given the long-term nature of retirement planning, this preliminary and short-term influence was perceived as comparatively minor, with sure provisions for adversarial deviation measures already in place to safeguard towards such fluctuations.
Turbulence within the monetary market additionally prompted firms to reassess their funding portfolios, with a larger emphasis on minimizing threat and in search of extra diversified funding choices. Whereas the funding technique is designed to resist market shocks, in my expertise, some firms have dialed again on riskier investments and prioritized stability and resilience in response to the financial challenges the pandemic posed.
Potential Outlooks
As we talked about earlier, some people need to work longer to make up for the lack of earnings brought on by the pandemic and are ready longer to faucet into their retirement funds. The evolution of the retirement age must be thought of in gentle of those modifications. The pandemic additionally highlighted the significance of strong retirement planning for people, with long-term shifts in planning methods after reevaluating retirement targets and threat tolerance. People might prioritize constructing bigger retirement nest eggs and emergency funds to raised put together for future crises.
From the attitude of insurance coverage firms, these evolving particular person behavioral shifts might form modifications in insurance coverage product choices and retirement planning methods, with a larger emphasis on flexibility. Firms may reply to a bunch of educated people who’re in search of recommendation or adjusting their funding portfolios. The pandemic accelerated the adoption of digital monetary companies, together with retirement planning instruments and funding platforms. Firms are navigating challenges to satisfy the evolving wants of retirees and pre-retirees in a post-pandemic world.
Cecelia Hubach, FCAS, MAAA, P&C Actuary and Supervisor at Ernst & Younger LLP
Most of my expertise is in private-passenger auto insurance coverage, and I’ll focus my remarks on this market. The auto insurance coverage market was hit instantly and considerably by the pandemic, however we are also seeing some second-degree impacts lengthy after the height of the pandemic. I’ll begin with some rapid responses to COVID-19 after which talk about second-degree impacts.
Quick Responses
As reports present, the rapid response to COVID-19 was a pointy drop in driving exercise, which led to a drastic discount within the variety of automobile crashes. This, in flip, resulted in bigger income for carriers throughout 2020 because of decrease claims payouts. Many vehicle insurance coverage carriers issued premium refunds to policyholders, recognizing the decreased threat they assumed throughout this era. Nevertheless, the influence of COVID-19 diversified throughout states, which made it difficult for carriers to research knowledge for pricing and potential charge changes. Key concerns included tips on how to interpret knowledge from the peak of the COVID-19 interval and the relevance and reliability of the information. Whereas ignoring the information completely could also be an possibility, doing so may probably overlook necessary insights into altering driving behaviors and threat profiles.
Second-degree Impacts
There was a rebound in accident frequency following the preliminary COVID-19 drop, though it’s nonetheless not fairly again to pre-pandemic ranges. Distant work preparations have led to much less time spent commuting. It’s necessary for carriers to acknowledge that this shift in conduct might persist, as many people have tailored to distant work and altered their commuting patterns accordingly. With distant work changing into extra prevalent, individuals may be spending much less time on acquainted home-to-work routes and may be spending extra time on leisure journeys and driving on unfamiliar routes. Various kinds of driving, corresponding to driving whereas on trip, might carry completely different ranges of threat in comparison with common commuting. For auto insurance coverage carriers, it’s necessary to not solely take a look at the general frequency, but additionally to grasp these shifts in driving conduct—it’s important for precisely assessing threat and setting applicable charges.
You may be questioning: If claims frequency continues to be under pre-pandemic ranges, why did my auto insurance coverage charge enhance a lot previously yr? The associated fee and severity of claims primarily drive the rise in insurance coverage premiums. Disruptions within the provide chain and labor shortages, coupled with inflationary pressures, have led to a lot larger restore prices for automobiles. Moreover, whereas accident frequency might have decreased initially through the pandemic, there may have been a corresponding enhance within the severity of accidents. This might be because of components corresponding to modifications in driving conduct and elevated speeds on much less congested roads.
Just like the automotive business, provide chain disruptions and labor shortages have led to larger prices for house insurance coverage. It is very important be aware that house insurance coverage prices are usually not instantly linked to the market worth of the house however are as a substitute primarily based on the price of repairs and reconstruction. This discrepancy between market worth and reconstruction value can result in underinsurance for householders. Many customers might not notice that their present protection won’t be ample to cowl the total value of rebuilding their house within the occasion of a declare. Whereas the premium might stay the identical, the protection won’t be ample to deal with the elevated prices of supplies and labor.
Issues to Monitor
The pandemic brought about disruptions within the manufacturing and provide chain processes inside the auto business, which resulted in a scarcity of recent automobiles, notably for the mannequin years 2021 and 2022. Manufacturing constraints and better value tags, coupled with elevated monetary uncertainties, led to extra people opting to carry onto their current automobiles for longer intervals. In consequence, there are fewer mannequin yr 2020 and 2021 automobiles on the highway, and the typical age of automobiles on the highway immediately is barely larger than earlier than the pandemic. Though there’s no rapid distortion in claims, it will be fascinating to observe the potential impacts.
Research exhibits that many individuals relocated through the pandemic. Insurers may contemplate the transitional influence when people relocate, as newcomers to an space might have completely different driving behaviors and threat profiles.
Lastly, I’d say the lasting impact of COVID-19 is the change in driving conduct, which is probably not reliably predicted primarily based on older knowledge. Carriers now have a wealth of post-COVID-19 knowledge which will present insights into the “new regular” of driving patterns. Carriers might wish to undertake extra subtle analytical approaches, corresponding to territorial evaluation, consideration of demographic shifts and extra granulated and segmented expertise research.
Statements of reality and opinions expressed herein are these of the person authors and are usually not essentially these of the Society of Actuaries or the respective authors’ employers.
Copyright © 2024 by the Society of Actuaries, Chicago, Illinois.
