PRIME NEWS POST
The INDONESIAN, (MEDAN)— Polri Watch has raised serious concerns over alleged unprofessional handling of a criminal case at the Medan Timur Police Sub‑Sector. The organisation has formally filed a complaint with the North Sumatra Regional Police Chief, c/o the Director of General Criminal Investigation, on Wednesday (18/11/2026), pointing to irregularities in the investigation process involving an assistant investigator identified by the initials Brigpol BYL, S.H.
The complaint highlights claims that several transfer‑proof documents for vendors were not included in the case dossier, even though the records had previously been submitted by a woman identified by the initial F during her witness questioning at Medan Timur Police Sub‑Sector on 6 October 2026.
Further, the documents in question are alleged to have been returned by the investigator to F’s legal counsel without the knowledge or consent of the person who originally handed them over.
Idam Harahap, S.H., Director of Public Complaints and Litigation for Polri Watch, explained the case stems from questioning related to Police Report Number LP/B/294/VII/2026/SPKT/POLSEK MEDAN TIMUR/POLRESTABES MEDAN/POLDA SUMATERA UTARA dated 17 July 2026.
Before the questioning session, F received a second witness summons, Number S.Pgl/Saksi.2/122.a/IX/2026/RESKRIM dated 26 September 2026, in which investigators specifically asked her to bring documents and evidence relevant to the case.
On 6 October 2026, F complied with the summons accompanied by her lawyer. During questioning, investigators asked about the use of the funds cited in the report. F responded by presenting several transfer receipts showing payments to vendors, documents potentially critical to tracing the flow and use of the disputed money.
According to Polri Watch’s submission, the investigator allegedly declined to record all of the transfer evidence in the official Examination Report (BAP), issuing a receipt only for a portion of the submitted documents, as noted in the Evidence Handover Report dated 6 October 2026. The situation has raised questions about how the documents were received, logged, stored, and evaluated throughout the investigation.
F Allegedly Named a Suspect After Submitting Evidence
The matter grew more concerning after F’s status was changed from witness to suspect via Determination Letter Number S.Tap.Tsk/192/X/2026/Reskrim dated 14 October 2026, followed by first and second suspect summonses on 15 October 2026 and 22 October 2026.
Polri Watch is questioning whether all of F’s statements and supporting documents from her witness interview were objectively reviewed before the decision to name her a suspect was made. The vendor‑transfer records, the group argues, should have been examined to test the prosecution’s case, including whether all required elements of the alleged offence were present.
Idam stressed that investigations must not focus solely on incriminating evidence; potentially exculpatory material must also be assessed in a fair, proportionate manner.
Transfer Evidence Allegedly Returned Without Consent
Information about the alleged return of the documents came to Idam Harahap from FW, F’s sibling, on Wednesday (18/11/2026). FW had sought clarification on Tuesday (17/11/2026) from the lawyer who represented F during the 6 October witness session.
Based on the information received by the complainant, several of the vendor‑transfer papers submitted to investigators had been given back to F’s legal representative — reportedly without F’s knowledge, approval, or even confirmation from her attorney.
The development has prompted a series of fundamental, transparency‑related questions: Why were documents handed over during questioning apparently not added to the case file? What formal procedure was followed for their return? Who authorised the decision, and was the original submitter properly notified? For Polri Watch, these are not merely administrative issues; they touch on the integrity and objectivity of the whole investigation.
Polri Watch Requests Probe Into Potential Evidence‑Tampering
The complaint also flags possible conduct that could relate to evidence destruction, referencing Article 278 of the 2023 Criminal Code. Polri Watch notes, however, that any application of the criminal provision must be proven through valid, verified facts, with the final assessment of whether a crime occurred falling to the authorised law‑enforcement bodies.
Idam Harahap said professional investigators must examine every set of facts completely, not only those that support one version of the case. He also suggested the transfer records be fully clarified, with input from criminal‑law experts if needed, to determine their relevance to the ongoing matter.
In the written complaint, Idam asked the North Sumatra Regional Police Chief and the Director of General Criminal Investigation to conduct a comprehensive review of the reported investigator’s actions, going beyond a simple administrative clarification. The review should trace the full timeline: document submission, recording, storage, and the reasoning and procedure behind the alleged return to the lawyer. Polri Watch also requested statements from every person involved in the handover and return process to ensure no detail is overlooked.
Law Enforcement Must Be Objective, Not One‑Sided
Idam called on the North Sumatra Police leadership to treat the complaint seriously, to guarantee professional, transparent, and fair law enforcement. The issue, he said, is bigger than a handful of returned documents; it concerns the constitutional guarantee that every person receives equal, objective legal treatment.
If relevant evidence was left unrecorded, ignored, or returned without clear procedure, Idam argued, the incident deserves serious scrutiny because it could undermine the fairness of the investigation. “The law must be sharp in finding fault, but also honest in examining all facts to reveal the complete picture of the case,” he said.
Polri Watch described the complaint as a form of public oversight, intended to encourage the police institution to preserve its professionalism, integrity, and public trust.
Source / Media Contact
Idam Harahap, S.H.
Director of Public Complaints and Litigation
Polri Watch
Reported from various media sources //photo from Google documents // contribution by Prime News Post international online media // news.paper












